There are two kinds of people in New York: those who say they are just going out for a scoop, and those who know perfectly well that an ice cream stop can become an entire afternoon. At Sugar Hill Creamery, the difference is mostly academic. You come for the ice cream; you stay because the place has a way of making a neighborhood feel a little more like itself.
Founded in Harlem in 2017 by husband-and-wife team Petrushka Bazin Larsen and Nick Larsen, Sugar Hill Creamery has grown into a Black-owned, woman-led, family-owned business with three year-round Harlem locations. Its premise is refreshingly direct: handmade, small-batch ice cream, thoughtful hospitality, and flavors that draw from the Caribbean, the Midwest, and the many cultures that make Harlem home.
Not just a sweet tooth
The first shop opened in the Mount Morris Park area after the founders recognized a gap in the neighborhood: Harlem needed a place for a genuinely good scoop, made with the care and craft they had found elsewhere in the city. The idea became a business, but the business was never only about dessert. Sugar Hill’s own language is about connection — turning strangers into neighbors, neighbors into friends, and friends into family.

That intention shows up in the details. The creamery makes handmade ice cream in small batches, with seasonal and classic options, as well as non-dairy and vegan choices. The founders describe their flavor point of view as a conversation between Caribbean and Midwestern food memories and the everyday life of Harlem. It is a generous way to think about a menu: not as a fixed list of flavors, but as a record of where people come from and what they carry with them.
Co-founder and CEO Petrushka Bazin Larsen brings a background in arts, education, and community organizing. Nick Larsen, the company’s co-founder and chief creative officer, brings a food and hospitality sensibility. Together, they have built a business where the product matters, but the setting and the welcome matter just as much.
The neighborhood is on the walls
Perhaps the most interesting part of Sugar Hill Creamery is what happens after you have chosen your flavor. The company’s current Our Story page describes portraits of Harlem residents displayed on the walls of its locations: neighbors, artists, educators, advocates, and community builders whose lives reflect the neighborhood’s many stories. The portrait series was commissioned for each location by Brooklyn-based artist Audrey Moffitt.

There is something quietly radical about that choice. A neighborhood business could use its walls to sell a lifestyle, or to decorate a room for photographs. Sugar Hill uses them to recognize the people who already make the neighborhood worth visiting. The effect is less like walking into a chain and more like being welcomed into a living scrapbook — one that keeps adding pages.
The creamery has also documented this impulse through its Harlemites project, an oral-history effort that collected residents’ stories and photographs. The archive explains that residents were profiled over the course of a year, with longer stories shared through the company’s email and images shared on Instagram. It is a reminder that local culture is not only found in institutions with marble steps. Sometimes it is gathered one conversation at a time, over a counter, in a shop where someone knows your order.
Three Harlem addresses, one neighborhood habit
Today, Sugar Hill Creamery lists three year-round Harlem shops. The Central Harlem location is at 184 Lenox Avenue, between 119th and 120th Streets. In West Harlem, the shop is at 3629 Broadway, between 149th and 150th Streets. East Harlem has its own location at 1642 Lexington Avenue, between 103rd and 104th Streets.

Hours vary by location and season. The current locations page lists Central Harlem as open from 2 p.m. to 11 p.m. on weekdays and noon to 11 p.m. on weekends; the West Harlem and East Harlem shops are listed from 2 p.m. to 11 p.m. daily. Because seasonal hours can change, the sensible New York move is to check the official locations page before heading out.
That three-neighborhood footprint matters. Harlem is not a single block or a single mood. Central, West, and East Harlem each have their own pace, landmarks, and daily rituals. A business that operates across all three has a chance to become part of how people move through the neighborhood — a stop after school, a post-dinner treat, a small celebration, or a reason to take the long way home.

And the creamery’s community work extends beyond the counter. Its website describes local collaborations and programs, and the founders’ approach makes room for gathering as much as buying. That is a meaningful distinction in a city where so many spaces are designed around the transaction. Here, the transaction is a scoop; the larger ambition is a place where people feel they belong.
What to order? Start with curiosity.
The best first visit is the one that leaves room for discovery. Ask what is seasonal. Ask what reflects the founders’ Caribbean and Midwestern inspirations. If you prefer dairy-free, the shop lists non-dairy and vegan options. If you are planning a celebration, Sugar Hill also offers custom cakes, ice cream cakes, and catering services, according to its official site.

And if you find yourself looking at the portraits before you decide on a flavor, that is part of the experience. The shop is offering a reminder that a neighborhood is made by people, not just by storefronts. A scoop can be a treat, but it can also be an introduction — to a local artist, a longtime resident, a story you might not otherwise have heard.
New York has plenty of places to get ice cream. What makes Sugar Hill Creamery worth knowing is the idea that a dessert shop can be a cultural address, too. It can honor the people who came before, make room for the people who are here now, and still give you an excellent reason to come back tomorrow.
Visit: 184 Lenox Avenue, 3629 Broadway, or 1642 Lexington Avenue, New York, NY. Hours and current menu vary by location and season.
Explore Sugar Hill Creamery’s story, current locations and hours, and the Harlemites archive.
Mood Magazine NYC — official culture guide, stories worth stepping into.